May 2009 St. Vincent: Actor

 
  1. The Strangers
  2. Save Me From What I Want
  3. The Neighbors
  4. Actor Out Of Work
  5. Black Rainbow
  6. Laughing With A Mouth Of Blood
  7. Marrow
  8. The Bed
  9. The Party
  10. Just The Same But Brand New
  11. The Sequel
The Art of Controlled Chaos

St. Vincent’s Actor is a paradox wrapped in technicolor - an album that smiles sweetly as it burns the frame around it. Annie Clark crafts a world where the domestic and the deranged collide, where pastel suburban calm gives way to a fever dream of distortion and dissonance. It’s the sound of beauty meticulously unravelling - elegant, unsettling, and absolutely riveting.

Clark doesn’t merely write songs; she stages them. Each composition feels like a scene from a psychological film, scored for both orchestra and malfunctioning circuit board. Strings swoon and guitars snarl, melodies shimmer and then collapse under their own weight - all while her voice, deceptively serene, narrates the emotional wreckage with surgical precision. There’s a theatrical intelligence at work here, but also a biting self-awareness: Actor performs the act of breaking down in perfect rhythm.

The genius of the album lies in its contradictions. It’s lush but claustrophobic, graceful yet unhinged - a modern fairy tale told through the lens of postmodern anxiety. Clark takes the tropes of femininity, perfection, and performance, and warps them into something alien and powerful. Her lyrics often read like stage directions for the psyche: a choreography of repression, rebellion, and release.

What makes Actor so magnetic is its balance of control and chaos. Every sound feels intentional, yet on the brink of collapse. The arrangements bloom like fireworks - dazzling, transient, a little dangerous. It’s an album that refuses to choose between emotional honesty and sonic experimentation; it insists that both can, and must, coexist.

By the end, Actor feels like stepping out of a vivid dream - disoriented but illuminated, carrying the strange afterglow of something both familiar and foreign. In this world, St. Vincent becomes both the director and the subject, the marionette and the hand that cuts the strings. Actor doesn’t just showcase her artistry; it declares it - a masterclass in turning vulnerability into spectacle, and chaos into exquisite control. 
 
=====
 
My personal view: 
For her second album Annie Erin Clark, known professionally as St. Vincent, watched films without the sound and composed music for her favourite scenes. The result is a dark and ambitious art pop gem, with sharp contrasts between and within songs, both musically and lyrically. I love the reaction of one critic:  "She has found her own voice - and it's one you wouldn't want reading your kids any bedtime stories." The quality is consistently high throughout the album, but a few highlights are The Strangers, Actor Out Of Work, Laughing With A Mouth Of Blood, Marrow, The Bed, and Just The Same But Brand New.